New Delhi, home to over 20 million people, took a major step towards climate mitigation when it banned all forms of single-use plastics in 2017. A few years later, the whole nation of India introduced a comparable ban. Yet, while plastics and plastic waste have been a huge burden in India, causing pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, it is also a source of income and livelihood for many waste pickers in India. So the question is, how can a Just Transition in plastic be encountered?
By Aishwaryaa Kunwar
A "Just Transition" is a pivotal concept in the pursuit of a greener and more sustainable future. It embodies the idea that when societies and economies transition away from polluting and unsustainable practices, the process of this very transition should be equitable and inclusive. Above all, it recognizes that environmental change should not come at the expense of vulnerable communities, workers, or livelihoods. Within the broader endeavor of a Just Transition, plastic pollution emerges as a particularly complex and pressing challenge. Known for their durability and versatility, plastics have infiltrated nearly every aspect of modern life. However, their environmental consequences have grown alarmingly evident. Single-use plastics, in particular, have become emblematic of a throwaway culture that burdens landfills and pollutes oceans. In India, the context of Just Transition takes on a unique and compounded dimension.
Dr. Shyamala Mani, from the Public Health Foundation of India, stresses that what we really need to look at is our priorities and the kind of impact it is having. ”We have to dramatically reduce plastics in our environment and more importantly, in our usage”. But beyond the need to reduce usage of plastics significantly, one has to take into account that India’s plastic problems mirror its complex social fabric. On one hand, plastic waste pervades the environment, threatening ecosystems and public health. As Kawar Bir Singh, founder of Indian Birds points out, “Plastics in our ecosystems are pervasive. They are in our ocean, mountain ranges, freshwater habitats, and around the cities''. On the other, however, there is an almost-invisible army, often marginalized and disregarded, that collects, sorts, and recycles this very plastic waste, making a living from a pursuit that society and policies often overlook.
For decades, plastic waste has been the backbone of the livelihoods of countless waste pickers in the country. Informal workers scour the streets, landfills, and even the sea shores for discarded plastics. They sort, clean, and sell these materials to recycling units, contributing significantly to the informal recycling sector in India, which accounts for nearly 90% of the recycling effort in the country. This sector is a lifeline for many, providing jobs for an estimated 4-5 million waste pickers across the nation.
In 2022, when India initiated the ban on single-use plastics, it intended to curb pollution and promote cleanliness. However, this move inadvertently marginalized the livelihood concerns of plastic waste pickers. While policies and awareness programs focused on the "littering issue," the underlying problems faced by these workers were often ignored.
Several initiatives are beginning to weave the threads of sustainability and social justice together. In Pune, for instance, SWaCH (Solid Waste Collection and Handling) cooperative empowers waste pickers by integrating them into the formal waste management system. This not only ensures better working conditions but also offers access to social security benefits like health care and education for their children.
Moreover, organizations like the All India Kabadi Mazdoor Mahasangh are advocating for the recognition of waste pickers as essential service providers, deserving of dignity, protection, and fair wages. These efforts are steps toward a Just Transition that honors the contributions of those who have long been invisible in the recycling chain.
Despite these promising initiatives, the path to a Just Transition in plastics is fraught with multifaceted challenges. The informal nature of their work leaves waste pickers vulnerable to exploitation, and they often face health hazards due to exposure to hazardous materials in the waste they collect. The growing privatization of waste management and the rise of waste-to-energy projects pose a significant threat to their traditional roles.
Additionally, the informal recycling sector faces competition from the influx of cheap virgin plastics, which discourages the recycling of existing materials. The introduction of Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) frameworks, which hold manufacturers accountable for the end-of-life disposal of their products, could further transform the recycling landscape and pose another form of competition for the informal recycling sector. India notified guidelines for the policy in 2022 and is therefore adapting to a system that, based on the 'polluter pays' principle, lays down responsibilities of all stakeholders engaged in the plastic industry and fines for violations. However, reports highlight that “only a proportion of producers, importers and brand owners have registered on a centralised portal that would track their plastic collection and recycling targets”. More work and effective implementation will be required for the country to reduce its plastic footprint, but also ways of adaptation for the informal sector of waste pickers needs to be discussed.
Jai Prakash Choudhary, General Secretary of Safai Sena, a collective of waste workers in Delhi puts the current state of affairs as follows: “Neither do we have a process of pre-empting harm and nor do we have a way of reducing material or in any way thinking of alternatives. We have no systemic way to do that.”
Another important factor in how waste management and a Just Transition are intervened is the prevalence of caste. The caste system that operates within India's waste management systems, influences the perceptions and treatment of waste pickers. Due to social stigma, waste pickers face pervasive social stigma, and their work is often considered "unclean”. They are subjected to social exclusion and discrimination. This system is built on and continues to sustain on Savarna notions of "purity" and "pollution," with certain tasks and occupations relegated to specific caste groups. As a result, waste picking, often viewed as a "polluting" occupation, is associated with marginalised caste communities, further perpetuating social inequities.
The SWaCH cooperative, which grew out of Pune’s local trade union for waste pickers and Kagad Kach Patra Kashtakari Panchayat (KKPKP), attempts to navigate this caste-based inequality with its worker-rights-oriented model, helming a pro-poor alternative to centralised waste collection. The cooperative and its operations are completely owned by the waste picker members themselves, most of whom are women from Dalit and marginalized castes.
This, however, is a rare example. Caste in India is deeply rooted and will require attention and action across various levels during a Just Transition. It poses a significant barrier to achieving a Just Transition in plastics in India. Addressing this issue requires not only environmental awareness but also a commitment to social justice, intersectionality and equity. India's journey toward a more sustainable future cannot truly be just unless it dismantles the chains of caste discrimination that persist in the realm of waste management.
The path ahead is challenging, but it is one that must be walked with determination, empathy, and a commitment to social justice.
Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR), as defined by OECD, is an environmental policy approach in which a producer’s responsibility for a product is extended to the post-consumer stage of a product’s life cycle.
EPR has been a growing environmental protection mechanism throughout the world since the 1980s and involves:
Typical EPR policy instruments:
EPR and the informal sector:
The views expressed in this article are not necessarily those of FES.
Bringing together the work of our offices in the region, we provide you with the latest news on current debates, insightful research and innovative visual outputs on geopolitics, climate and energy, gender justice, trade unions and social-ecological transformation.
Since reports emerged that South Korean troops massacred civilians during the Vietnam War, there has been a fitful but determined effort by Vietnamese... More
Trade unions are drivers for transformative change. For sustainable change, gender justice is indispensable. Therefore, trade unions have to transform... More
South Korea's militaristic culture is fuelled by a history of conflict and maintained by a tradition of jingoistic, state-sponsored celebrations.... More
This site uses third-party website tracking technologies to provide and continually improve our services, and to display advertisements according to users' interests. I agree and may revoke or change my consent at any time with effect for the future.
These technologies are required to activate the core functionality of the website.
This is an self hosted web analytics platform.
Data Purposes
This list represents the purposes of the data collection and processing.
Technologies Used
Data Collected
This list represents all (personal) data that is collected by or through the use of this service.
Legal Basis
In the following the required legal basis for the processing of data is listed.
Retention Period
The retention period is the time span the collected data is saved for the processing purposes. The data needs to be deleted as soon as it is no longer needed for the stated processing purposes.
The data will be deleted as soon as they are no longer needed for the processing purposes.
These technologies enable us to analyse the use of the website in order to measure and improve performance.
This is a video player service.
Processing Company
Google Ireland Limited
Google Building Gordon House, 4 Barrow St, Dublin, D04 E5W5, Ireland
Location of Processing
European Union
Data Recipients
Data Protection Officer of Processing Company
Below you can find the email address of the data protection officer of the processing company.
https://support.google.com/policies/contact/general_privacy_form
Transfer to Third Countries
This service may forward the collected data to a different country. Please note that this service might transfer the data to a country without the required data protection standards. If the data is transferred to the USA, there is a risk that your data can be processed by US authorities, for control and surveillance measures, possibly without legal remedies. Below you can find a list of countries to which the data is being transferred. For more information regarding safeguards please refer to the website provider’s privacy policy or contact the website provider directly.
Worldwide
Click here to read the privacy policy of the data processor
https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
Click here to opt out from this processor across all domains
https://safety.google/privacy/privacy-controls/
Click here to read the cookie policy of the data processor
https://policies.google.com/technologies/cookies?hl=en
Storage Information
Below you can see the longest potential duration for storage on a device, as set when using the cookie method of storage and if there are any other methods used.
This service uses different means of storing information on a user’s device as listed below.
This cookie stores your preferences and other information, in particular preferred language, how many search results you wish to be shown on your page, and whether or not you wish to have Google’s SafeSearch filter turned on.
This cookie measures your bandwidth to determine whether you get the new player interface or the old.
This cookie increments the views counter on the YouTube video.
This is set on pages with embedded YouTube video.
This is a service for displaying video content.
Vimeo LLC
555 West 18th Street, New York, New York 10011, United States of America
United States of America
Privacy(at)vimeo.com
https://vimeo.com/privacy
https://vimeo.com/cookie_policy
This cookie is used in conjunction with a video player. If the visitor is interrupted while viewing video content, the cookie remembers where to start the video when the visitor reloads the video.
An indicator of if the visitor has ever logged in.
Registers a unique ID that is used by Vimeo.
Saves the user's preferences when playing embedded videos from Vimeo.
Set after a user's first upload.
This is an integrated map service.
Gordon House, 4 Barrow St, Dublin 4, Ireland
https://support.google.com/policies/troubleshooter/7575787?hl=en
United States of America,Singapore,Taiwan,Chile
http://www.google.com/intl/de/policies/privacy/