Vietnam’s rapid urbanization is bringing both opportunities and challenges. Among the most significant challenges is the preservation of cultural heritage in the face of modernization.
By Sơn Thanh Tùng, Nguyễn Hoàng Ngọc Thanh and Nguyễn Tấn Khanh, University of Social Sciences and Humanities, VNU-HCM, with the support of Pham Thi Bich Nga, FES
Vietnam’s rapid urbanization is bringing both opportunities and challenges. Among the most significant challenges is the preservation of cultural heritage in the face of modernization. This opinion piece explores the transformation of cultural identity in two ancient villages, Lu Cam and Phu Vinh, in Nha Trang city, in the central coastal province of Khanh Hoa, as they navigate the tides of urbanization.
Lu Cam and Phu Vinh, both more than 200 years old, offer contrasting narratives of cultural preservation. Lu Cam, once renowned for its traditional pottery, has seen its cultural identity erode rapidly. In contrast, Phu Vinh has managed to sustain its more multi-faceted cultural heritage, maintaining a vibrant community life centred around its ancient traditions.
Lu Cam’s decline is a poignant reminder of the fragility of cultural heritage in the face of economic and technological changes. The village’s once-thriving pottery industry has all but disappeared. Several factors have contributed to this decline:
Economic pressures: The market for traditional pottery has dwindled as modern, mass-produced alternatives have become more popular. The relatively high cost of traditional production led to low profitability, making pottery an unsustainable livelihood for many villagers.
Technological stagnation: The lack of innovation in pottery techniques and the failure to adapt to new technologies left Lu Cam’s products unable to compete with more durable and precise industrial ceramics.
Environmental challenges: The village’s location along the Cai River subjected it to seasonal flooding, disrupting production cycles and further discouraging pottery making.
Community disinterest: Perhaps most critically, there was a noticeable lack of community interest in preserving the pottery tradition. Many younger villagers sought employment opportunities elsewhere, leading to a loss of skilled artisans and a weakening of community bonds.
Efforts by local authorities to integrate pottery with tourism and provide economic support were insufficient to revive the craft. The communal centre, once a hub of cultural activity, now stands as a symbol of a lost heritage, with its traditional festivals and rituals struggling to attract participation.
In stark contrast, Phu Vinh has managed to preserve its cultural identity through a combination of community cohesion, economic diversification, and a strong sense of heritage. The village’s success can be attributed to several key factors:
Economic diversification: Unlike Lu Cam’s, Phu Vinh’s economy is not solely reliant on a single craft. The village has embraced a variety of businesses, from agriculture to tourism. This has provided a stable economic base and reduced the pressure on any one industry.
Community engagement: Phu Vinh’s residents have a deep sense of pride in their heritage. Festivals and rituals are well attended, and there is a strong tradition of community involvement in maintaining cultural sites and organizing events.
Government support: While not perfect, the local government’s efforts to promote tourism and preserve cultural sites have had a positive impact. The village’s ancient houses and communal spaces are well maintained, attracting both domestic and international tourists.
Intergenerational transmission: The elders in Phu Vinh play a crucial role in passing down traditions and cultural knowledge to younger generations. This has helped maintain a continuity of cultural practices and a sense of identity among the villagers.
The contrasting experiences of Lu Cam and Phu Vinh offer valuable lessons for heritage preservation in the context of urbanization. Firstly, economic viability is crucial. Heritage crafts and traditions must find a place in the modern economy, whether through tourism, innovation, or diversification. Secondly, community engagement and pride in cultural heritage are essential. Without a committed community, preservation efforts are unlikely to succeed.
Moreover, government policies must be tailored to the specific needs and contexts of different heritage sites. A one-size-fits-all approach is ineffective. Policies should support both the economic and cultural aspects of heritage preservation, providing resources for innovation and adaptation while also fostering community involvement.
Finally, the role of education and intergenerational transmission cannot be overstated. Ensuring that younger generations understand and value their cultural heritage is key to its survival. This requires not only formal education but also community-based initiatives that engage young people in cultural practices.
The stories of Lu Cam and Phu Vinh highlight the complex interplay between urbanization and cultural heritage. While urbanization brings challenges, it also offers opportunities for renewal and innovation. By learning from these two villages, we can develop more effective strategies for preserving cultural identity in the face of modernization. Ultimately, the preservation of cultural heritage is not just about protecting the past; it is about enriching the present and ensuring a vibrant, diverse future for all communities.
Son Thanh Tung is a lecturer at the Faculty of Urban Studies, University of Social Sciences and Humanities, VNU-HCM, received a PhDs in public policy and has conducted a number of research projects in the fields of poverty, environment, livelihoods and climate change.
Nguyen Hoang Ngoc Thanh and Nguyen Tan Khanh are students from the Faculty of Urban Studies, University of Social Sciences and Humanities, VNU-HCM, have conducted research on the traditional villages in Nha Trang city. Their dedication and competence have led to significant findings, forming the basis of this article.
An endeavour in Central Vietnam is bringing sustainable illumination to the area’s traditional Katu ethnic homes. The Duông house project in Quảng Nam…
Bringing together the work of our offices in the region, we provide you with the latest news on current debates, insightful research and innovative visual outputs on geopolitics, climate and energy, gender justice, trade unions and social-ecological transformation.
Since reports emerged that South Korean troops massacred civilians during the Vietnam War, there has been a fitful but determined effort by Vietnamese... More
Trade unions are drivers for transformative change. For sustainable change, gender justice is indispensable. Therefore, trade unions have to transform... More
South Korea's militaristic culture is fuelled by a history of conflict and maintained by a tradition of jingoistic, state-sponsored celebrations.... More
This site uses third-party website tracking technologies to provide and continually improve our services, and to display advertisements according to users' interests. I agree and may revoke or change my consent at any time with effect for the future.
These technologies are required to activate the core functionality of the website.
This is an self hosted web analytics platform.
Data Purposes
This list represents the purposes of the data collection and processing.
Technologies Used
Data Collected
This list represents all (personal) data that is collected by or through the use of this service.
Legal Basis
In the following the required legal basis for the processing of data is listed.
Retention Period
The retention period is the time span the collected data is saved for the processing purposes. The data needs to be deleted as soon as it is no longer needed for the stated processing purposes.
The data will be deleted as soon as they are no longer needed for the processing purposes.
These technologies enable us to analyse the use of the website in order to measure and improve performance.
This is a video player service.
Processing Company
Google Ireland Limited
Google Building Gordon House, 4 Barrow St, Dublin, D04 E5W5, Ireland
Location of Processing
European Union
Data Recipients
Data Protection Officer of Processing Company
Below you can find the email address of the data protection officer of the processing company.
https://support.google.com/policies/contact/general_privacy_form
Transfer to Third Countries
This service may forward the collected data to a different country. Please note that this service might transfer the data to a country without the required data protection standards. If the data is transferred to the USA, there is a risk that your data can be processed by US authorities, for control and surveillance measures, possibly without legal remedies. Below you can find a list of countries to which the data is being transferred. For more information regarding safeguards please refer to the website provider’s privacy policy or contact the website provider directly.
Worldwide
Click here to read the privacy policy of the data processor
https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
Click here to opt out from this processor across all domains
https://safety.google/privacy/privacy-controls/
Click here to read the cookie policy of the data processor
https://policies.google.com/technologies/cookies?hl=en
Storage Information
Below you can see the longest potential duration for storage on a device, as set when using the cookie method of storage and if there are any other methods used.
This service uses different means of storing information on a user’s device as listed below.
This cookie stores your preferences and other information, in particular preferred language, how many search results you wish to be shown on your page, and whether or not you wish to have Google’s SafeSearch filter turned on.
This cookie measures your bandwidth to determine whether you get the new player interface or the old.
This cookie increments the views counter on the YouTube video.
This is set on pages with embedded YouTube video.
This is a service for displaying video content.
Vimeo LLC
555 West 18th Street, New York, New York 10011, United States of America
United States of America
Privacy(at)vimeo.com
https://vimeo.com/privacy
https://vimeo.com/cookie_policy
This cookie is used in conjunction with a video player. If the visitor is interrupted while viewing video content, the cookie remembers where to start the video when the visitor reloads the video.
An indicator of if the visitor has ever logged in.
Registers a unique ID that is used by Vimeo.
Saves the user's preferences when playing embedded videos from Vimeo.
Set after a user's first upload.
This is an integrated map service.
Gordon House, 4 Barrow St, Dublin 4, Ireland
https://support.google.com/policies/troubleshooter/7575787?hl=en
United States of America,Singapore,Taiwan,Chile
http://www.google.com/intl/de/policies/privacy/