Why are people in Vietnam increasingly quitting social security system? Labour representative, Vu Minh Tien, looks at pressures driving this trend in recent years and outlines urgent steps to reduce the pressures on citizens to cash out of the social security system.
This year Vietnam witnessed a seemingly rather odd practice. Hoards of people have been queuing up overnight making one-time withdrawals of their entire social security funds. Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung spoke with a labour representative about the pressures driving the trend, the potential scope of the problem, and possible solutions.
“If this situation continues, it will be worrisome because currently there are only about 17.5 million people participating in the social insurance scheme,” said Vu Minh Tien, director of the Institute for Workers and Trade Unions. The World Bank estimates the country’s workforce at 55 million, for a population of 98 million.
“Workers choose the one-time withdrawal despite knowing its disadvantages, mainly because of economic reasons: poverty and debt pressure,” Tien said. “Some desperately need VND10-20 million [USD420-840] to pay off high-interest so-called ‘hot’ loans, medical expenses for family members, or even to take care of daily expenses such as rent payments.”
From 2016 to 2021, 4.06 million people participating in social insurance chose the one-time withdrawal, pulling a total of VND131.94 trillion (US$5.56 billion) out of the system, according to a VNExpress news report in March citing the Ministry of Labor, Invalids and Social Affairs. More than three-quarters of them were aged 20-40, it said.
The Covid-19 pandemic and associated layoffs have accelerated the withdrawals. The number of people cashing out in 2021 and 2022 combined was 1.85 million, a significant increase in the annual rate.
The potential consequences range from the short to the long term, and are likely to impact workers and their families, as well as the social security system, Tien explained. The most affected will be lower-income workers, who risk facing sickness or old age with no savings, pension, or health insurance, “becoming a burden for their relatives and society,” he said.
Tien outlined several urgent steps to reduce the pressures on citizens to cash out of the social security system, and also to increase the appeal of remaining within it.
“In order for workers to not choose one-time withdrawals it is critical that their salary meet the cost of living and secure some savings – over and above social security contributions – to cover the risk of illness, or loss or reduction of income.”
In addition, “the government and trade unions of all levels need to better communicate the benefits of the state's social security system in general, and of each social insurance regime in particular,” he said. “We need to help workers to understand the long-term disadvantages for themselves, their families and the whole of society if they opt out.”
Another initiative, he explained, could be for banks to cooperate with the state agencies handling the withdrawals. When faced with an application, these agencies could offer a comparable amount as a loan instead, with appropriate interest and extendable repayment periods. The one-time withdrawal would not be made, but that money used as collateral, he suggested. “This would be a solution chosen by many workers to both solve their immediate [cash-flow] problems and prolong their social insurance participation,” he said.
Several legislative reforms at government level would help further, Tien said, namely:
- amending the Law on Social Insurance to ensure the flexibility of payment and enjoyment of social insurance, and to be suitable for different labour groups;
- introducing specific support mechanisms (e.g. unsecured credit and microfinance) for disadvantaged groups such as low-income migrant, sick or injured workers, or households where all breadwinners lose their job at the same time;
- enforcing rules around contributions, strengthening inspections and handling of violations of social insurance payment such as: not paying, delaying, paying lower rates compared to regulations;
- ensuring equality of voluntary with compulsory social insurance; and
- expanding compulsory social insurance participation, in particular to informal workers.
Several proposed amendments to the Social Insurance Law are scheduled for discussion at the National Assembly in October, the VNExpress report said. One would make workers eligible for their pension after 15 years of contributions, down from the current 20, to encourage them to remain in the system. Another proposal would reduce the amount of the one-off withdrawal to half of previous contributions, rather than the total.
Tien said the government’s overall objective should be a strategic roadmap towards a universal social insurance. Such a task would be “a long-term and difficult ordeal, but necessary.”
Vu Minh Tien is director of the Institute for Workers and Trade Unions. He obtained a Doctor of Law degree and has been doing research on labour, trade union, industrial relations and related policies and law for more than 20 years. He was chief author of 3 monographs, leader of a national-level research topic and 7 ministry-level research topics. He also participated in 4 international research projects in Vietnam.
The unnoticed workforce in urban waste management and environmental protection
The Fourth Industrial Revolution has created many impacts on all aspects of life, especially the employment issues of workers. The Federal Government…
At this match, "the Ball" is not only for kicking, but is also about forging solidarity between people to take action for a better world. Vietnamese…
In the era of automation and digitization, qualification and training requirements for workers are undergoing drastic changes. Candidates, especially…
Bringing together the work of our offices in the region, we provide you with the latest news on current debates, insightful research and innovative visual outputs on geopolitics, climate and energy, gender justice, trade unions and social-ecological transformation.
Since reports emerged that South Korean troops massacred civilians during the Vietnam War, there has been a fitful but determined effort by Vietnamese... More
Trade unions are drivers for transformative change. For sustainable change, gender justice is indispensable. Therefore, trade unions have to transform... More
South Korea's militaristic culture is fuelled by a history of conflict and maintained by a tradition of jingoistic, state-sponsored celebrations.... More
This site uses third-party website tracking technologies to provide and continually improve our services, and to display advertisements according to users' interests. I agree and may revoke or change my consent at any time with effect for the future.
These technologies are required to activate the core functionality of the website.
This is an self hosted web analytics platform.
Data Purposes
This list represents the purposes of the data collection and processing.
Technologies Used
Data Collected
This list represents all (personal) data that is collected by or through the use of this service.
Legal Basis
In the following the required legal basis for the processing of data is listed.
Retention Period
The retention period is the time span the collected data is saved for the processing purposes. The data needs to be deleted as soon as it is no longer needed for the stated processing purposes.
The data will be deleted as soon as they are no longer needed for the processing purposes.
These technologies enable us to analyse the use of the website in order to measure and improve performance.
This is a video player service.
Processing Company
Google Ireland Limited
Google Building Gordon House, 4 Barrow St, Dublin, D04 E5W5, Ireland
Location of Processing
European Union
Data Recipients
Data Protection Officer of Processing Company
Below you can find the email address of the data protection officer of the processing company.
https://support.google.com/policies/contact/general_privacy_form
Transfer to Third Countries
This service may forward the collected data to a different country. Please note that this service might transfer the data to a country without the required data protection standards. If the data is transferred to the USA, there is a risk that your data can be processed by US authorities, for control and surveillance measures, possibly without legal remedies. Below you can find a list of countries to which the data is being transferred. For more information regarding safeguards please refer to the website provider’s privacy policy or contact the website provider directly.
Worldwide
Click here to read the privacy policy of the data processor
https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en
Click here to opt out from this processor across all domains
https://safety.google/privacy/privacy-controls/
Click here to read the cookie policy of the data processor
https://policies.google.com/technologies/cookies?hl=en
Storage Information
Below you can see the longest potential duration for storage on a device, as set when using the cookie method of storage and if there are any other methods used.
This service uses different means of storing information on a user’s device as listed below.
This cookie stores your preferences and other information, in particular preferred language, how many search results you wish to be shown on your page, and whether or not you wish to have Google’s SafeSearch filter turned on.
This cookie measures your bandwidth to determine whether you get the new player interface or the old.
This cookie increments the views counter on the YouTube video.
This is set on pages with embedded YouTube video.
This is a service for displaying video content.
Vimeo LLC
555 West 18th Street, New York, New York 10011, United States of America
United States of America
Privacy(at)vimeo.com
https://vimeo.com/privacy
https://vimeo.com/cookie_policy
This cookie is used in conjunction with a video player. If the visitor is interrupted while viewing video content, the cookie remembers where to start the video when the visitor reloads the video.
An indicator of if the visitor has ever logged in.
Registers a unique ID that is used by Vimeo.
Saves the user's preferences when playing embedded videos from Vimeo.
Set after a user's first upload.
This is an integrated map service.
Gordon House, 4 Barrow St, Dublin 4, Ireland
https://support.google.com/policies/troubleshooter/7575787?hl=en
United States of America,Singapore,Taiwan,Chile
http://www.google.com/intl/de/policies/privacy/